Pallavi Karnam
Mediation should become new mantra among lawyers: Justice M.N. Venkatachalaiah
Speaking at Legal Leadership Conclave, he said there was a loss of Rs 2 lakh crore per year as legal cases drag on and called for technological intervention.
Bengaluru: Mediation should become the new mantra among lawyers before it escalates to any level, opined Justice M.N. Venkatachalaiah, former Chief Justice of India.
Speaking at the inauguration of the one-day Legal Leadership Conclave on “Challenges and Future of Arbitration and Mediation in India,” organised by India Legal Research Foundation, Justice Venkatachalaiah said with increasing number of litigants and cases, it was high time the country accepted and adopted mediation and arbitration as a formal legal route.
“We have 34 million pending cases across the country. Of the 22,000 subordinate courts in the country, there are a minimum of 120 litigants and 120 Lawyer’s plus witnesses who visit these courts everyday. Most of the time, they go back empty handed as their matters are delayed. This is a precious loss of man hours and we should not allow it to come to such a stage.”
Pegging such delays in economic terms, the justice said there would be a notional loss of Rs 2 lakh crore per year due to such delays. “Even if a reasonable amount of Rs 200 was spent by every person, the amount of money wasted in prolonged litigation and court visits is enormous,” he pointed out.
Justice Venkatachalaiah said the judiciary should adopt new tools and technology that will speed up the process and mitigate delays. “Recognising and giving more importance to arbitration and mediation of disputes is one way to reduce pending cases. Appointing more number of judges is not the answer as this also adds to spending,” he said.
The former CJ also said technology should be used to the optimum and even the use of Artificial Intelligence would be a big step. By just spending 5% of this cost in alternative dispute resolution mechanism, the people can benefit enormously. The Prime Minister, Law Minister and other stake holders should own up to this problem. “In days of digital dictatorship and digital divide, mediation is the right way in arbitration,” he added.
Union Minister for Highways, Nitin Gadkari said there was an economic slowdown in infrastructure building, especially in his sector of national highways, as contractors were being affected hugely due to delays in litigation.
Speaking from New Delhi, via a live feed, Shri Gadkari wished the conclave all the best and said time was very important and acknowledged that in many cases of litigations, arbitration was the best way ahead for the country.
Justice B.N. Srikrishna, former Supreme Court judge, who headed a committee and gave recommendations on mediation as a forward looking idea, said even sovereign states should get into bilateral treaties and arbitration before third parties impose anything.
He spoke on “Challenges and Reforms in Indian Arbitration and Mediation System – Way Forward” and said the 2015 Act was very clear as it was recognised as a cut-off-date as far as arbitration of disputes were concerned.
Justice Srikrishna also stressed on the fact that it is better to have institutional arbitration especially with Supreme Court and High Courts supervising such institutions.
“The future challenge is to make effective use of the new law which is a relevant and live substitute for antiquated laws,” he added.
Justice T.S. Thakur, former Chief Justice of India, who moderated the session, said the main challenge was that anyone should be able to access the arbitration mechanism. “Even a small municipal contractor should have easy access to the arbitration mechanism to settle his dispute.”
He was also of the opinion that India should build an international and domestic arbitration hub.
Justice Alok Aradhe, Karnataka High Court judge and President of the Arbitration Centre said arbitration as a means of redressal featured even in the Upanishads. “It’s a very old system that we need to have. As there is a rapid escalation of trade, Parliament is bringing in Acts. These Acts facilitate quick disposal of commercial matters,” he said while speaking on “Challenges to Arbitral Awards – Commercial Courts and need for training of judges.”
He said State judicial academies should train judges in modern methods of arbitration.
